The objective of a freight bid project is to secure a range of carriers and logistics service providers that are best able to supply a shipper with the service (e.g. transit times, customer service, shipment tracking information), capacity (e.g. drivers, tractors, trailers, straight trucks) and pricing to ensure the company has a competitive advantage in the market. It takes time to do this right.

If your company has conducted a professional bidding exercise, you should be able to rank your service providers on a set of variables at the end of the first round of bidding. If the bidding process has been conducted effectively, there will likely be some significant cost savings, particularly for companies that have not gone to the market for several years.

There is a temptation on the part of some shippers to “take the money and run.” This could be a big mistake.

There are thousands of freight carriers, load brokers and logistics service providers throughout North America. One of the important elements of an effective freight bid is to seek out those carriers that can provide the best combination of service, capacity and rates to meet the unique needs of your business.

Over the years, we have observed some companies that do freight RFP exercises but limit the carriers they contact to the same group of companies year after year. My colleagues and I will hear comments like “we used that carrier in 2002 but their service was poor” or “most carriers in that lane have the same rates” or “we know the carriers that can handle our freight effectively.” It is our view that conducting an RFP is a great time to learn more about the various players in the industry.

Times change and so do carriers. New management will strengthen some carriers while weakening others. The quality level can vary significantly from carrier to carrier.  There can be a wide disparity between carriers in their ability to serve certain geographic areas.  

In order to conduct a freight RFP exercise, shippers need to secure historical data on their traffic volumes by type of service (e.g. small parcel, LTL, over the road truckload, intermodal etc.) and freight costs by lane (e.g. origin – destination pair). The data serves two purposes. First, by capturing and sharing shipment activity data, it guides the carriers in creating their bids by helping them understand how the freight will impact their business. Second, the freight cost data serves as a benchmark against which to compare the rates and other carrier data (e.g. transit times) that are received.

To create an accurate data base, the following key elements are required:

a) For small parcel shipments, origin and destination postal codes are essential.

In an RFP, the carriers are being asked to bid on specific types of freight moving on specific traffic lanes. The rates they quote are based on the freight descriptions that you provide. It is essential that all aspects of the freight be documented in sufficient detail so as to ensure the quotes received are an exact match for the freight being shipped. These are some of the areas that require their input.

a) What do typical shipments look like (e.g. pallets, pieces, a combo, drums, totes etc.)?

b) What are the precise dimensions and weights of the freight?

c) How is the freight loaded and unloaded (e.g. crane, fork lift, lumper service, side loading, apartment deliveries etc.)?

Over the past eleven years, my colleagues and I have worked on a variety of successful freight RFP or freight bid projects. During that time, we have observed a number of factors that are the keys to success. This is the first in a series of blogs that will provide tips on how to run a successful freight bid.

1. Obtain Buy-in and Participation from the Operating Divisions

In some multi-plant or multi-division companies, the RFP project is approved by the head office CFO or President. While the divisions may pay the carrier freight invoices, their participation in the RFP may be limited to reviewing the proposed carrier list or bid documents or simply being made aware that the project will be undertaken. This is not adequate.

Since the division managers are directly involved with shipping and receiving goods on a daily basis, they often have information that head office personnel don’t have. It is essential that these people be engaged at the beginning, at key milestones throughout the project and at the end to ensure a successful project. The division freight personnel should be asked to not just read status requests or respond to written requests for information; rather they should also be engaged in conference calls on specific topics (e.g. freight loading and unloading requirements, documentation of local cartage runs, pick-up and delivery requirements in specific branches etc.) so the bid documents completely and accurately reflect the shipping characteristics of your firm.