Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in Best Practices in Freight Management
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 1982
  • 0 Comments
  • Print

Will Shippers and Carriers ever be able to Trust Each Other?

b2ap3_thumbnail_dreamstime_xl_49902079_20190529-162845_1.jpg

 

It is hard to believe that a decade has gone by since the Great Recession. Those of us in the Freight Transportation Industry at that time remember the sharp drop in business activity and freight volumes. This encouraged many shippers to conduct multiple freight bids during that period to use (abuse) their freight rate negotiating leverage to reduce their shipping costs. Carrier loyalty was sacrificed for freight cost savings.

One year ago, the tables were totally reversed. The introduction of electronic logging devices (ELDs) combined with an upswing in economic activity and a capacity shortage pushed freight rates to record levels. Carriers became very selective in allocating their capacity. Manufacturers and distributors were advised to become “Shippers of Choice.”

Carriers gave preference to shippers whose facilities were “driver friendly,” whose loads and paperwork were ready in a timely manner, who moved loads to preferred locations, and who paid top dollar. Shippers that wished to maintain consistent, reliable capacity and service were encouraged to establish “core carrier” programs at “carrier friendly” rates. They were told to pay the newly elevated rates to protect their supply chains.

At mid-year 2019, the tables have turned again. While economic conditions are good, they are not as robust as 2018. To address last year’s equipment shortfall, many carriers purchased fleet equipment. To retain drivers, most trucking fleets raised their driver wages. There is now ample capacity in the market. Looking at the most recent DAT Market Review (https://www.dat.com/industry-trends/trendlines), spot market loads are down 53.5% as compared to last year, spot market capacity is up 42.3 % while the van-load-to-truck ratio is down 58.9%.

What about those manufacturers that created core carrier programs and become “Shippers of Choice?” Anecdotal evidence suggests that some carriers that invested in equipment, committed to placing this equipment on specific shipper lanes, and trained their personnel to monitor the capacity and service on these corridors, are seeing shortfalls in their anticipated freight volumes. Given the opportunity to cover some loads with other carriers or brokers at lower rates, some shippers are opting for cost saving over commitment.

This is not surprising. I have been in the freight business for over 35 years and have seen this behavior repeated many times. It is sad commentary on our industry that after going from one extreme to the other over the past decade, shippers and carriers don’t recognize the benefits that come from enduring, committed relationships. They cannot commit to a partnership where over the long term, both parties win. Shippers achieve dependable capacity and service at fair rates; carriers receive dependable freight volumes at profitable rates.

When they need trucks, shippers talk about partnership, driver issues, appointment scheduling and load commitments. However, when capacity is readily available, some revert to lower cost options. Similarly, in a very buoyant freight year, some carriers abandoned their commitments so they could offer their capacity to the highest bidder. Some carriers went overboard and bought excess equipment. They are now stuck with a larger than necessary fleet and inflated driver wages.

We all understand that shippers are under great pressure to keep their logistics costs as low as possible to maximize profits. I am not sure that all shippers understand that it is costly to run a high-quality trucking company. In addition to equipment and salaries, there are considerable expenses associated with operating a safe, compliant, properly insured, financially stable business that is well managed, where the staff are well trained, where employees are motivated to provide superior customer service, that has up-to-date technology and there is ample equipment to meet a range of needs. Shippers that sacrifice quality for short term cost savings place their supply chains at unnecessary risk.

Freight Recessions and Capacity Shortages will reoccur. It is sad that some shippers and carriers are not able to commit to lasting partnerships based on open communication and trust. Hopefully the lessons of the past ten years will be a driving force for trust and change.

 

To stay up to date on Best Practices in Freight Management, follow me on Twitter @DanGoodwill, join the Freight Management Best Practices group on LinkedIn and subscribe to Dan’s Transportation Newspaper (http://paper.li/DanGoodwill/1342211466).

0

Comments

  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Friday, 29 March 2024

Most Recent Posts

Search


Tag Cloud

Sales Strategy customer engagement cyber security solutions provider drones Amazon Accessorial Charges BNSF CP Rail freight payment NMFC BlueGrace Logistics Inbound Transportation Doug Nix Celadon shipper-carrier roundtable technology David Tuttle ShipMax Broker Dan Goodwill Freight Shuttle System Muhammad Ali CSA shipper-carrier contracts freight cost savings network optimization 2015 Economic Forecast Spanx Electric Vehicles Freight Rates Business Strategy University of Tennessee Associates Global experience Hudsons Bay Company JB Hunt Success failure entrepreneur trade RFP natural disasters Online grocery shopping UP Canadian Transportation & Logistics Canada Rate per Mile selling trucking companies 2014 freight forecast Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC Swift CN Rail Driving for Profit energy efficiency Life Lessons Load broker buying trucking companies Doug Davis driverless Retail MPG laptop YRCW bulk shipping Coronavirus Consulting derailments Canadian truckers Fire Phone Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration Freight Matching recession dark stores capacity shortages freight rate increases Sales Training routing guide freight transportation conference Infrastructure small parcel Loblaw Truckload Werner Colilers International USMCA Transloading Impeachment 360ideaspace dynamic pricing Leadership Geopolitics Freight 2014 freight volumes business start-up Microsoft Stephen Harper Trade Vision Covid-19 LTL Blockchain freight agreements Carriers economic outlook FCA Management Whole Foods Retail transportation Driver Shortage online shopping Freight Recession Tracy Matura last mile delivery TMP Worldwide ProMiles $75000 bond China Surety bond truck drivers Training Canadian economy LCV's Bobby Harris the future of transportation Trucker Protest US Economy Masters in Logistics supply chain management Uber Freight employee termination Harper Davos speech Habs Toronto Maple Leafs automation Business Transformation Strategy fuel surcharge Software Advice peak season Otto Freight Capacity FuelQuest mentoring Climate Change freight transportation in 2011 asset management Cleveland Cavaliers Transportation Grocery LinkedIn Freight contracts Deferred Packaging Politics ELD home delivery shipping wine Packaging Leafs truck capacity CSX Wal-Mart CN Government cheap oil Right Shoring future of freight industry Rotman School of Business Transplace risk management freight forwarders US Housing Market shipping freight marketplace autos intermodal Canadian Protests US Manufacturing Crisis management Twitter business security President Obama Map-21 capacity shortage General Motors TMS Railway Association of Canada consumer centric Trump Finance and Transportation Outsourcing Sales Tariffs freight broker hiring process Canadian freight market Yield Improvement Success freight payment freight audit Blogging Digital Freight Networks Crude Oil by Rail 2014 economic forecast 3PL MBA economic forecasts for 2012 Distribution e-commerce computer Value Proposition Keystone Pipeline small business APL Job satisfaction Transportation Buying Trends Survey Load Boards freight costs Hockey marketing Digitization 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad pipelines FCPC broker bonds driver Toronto Shipper transportation newspaper shipper-carrier collaboration KCS carrier conference Warehousing autonomous vehicles rail safety transportation news Sales Management NCC Dedicated Contract Carriage CSA scores Trucking Freight Carriers Association of Canada Canada U.S. trade EBOR Canada's global strategy freight RFP TransForce Conway Education Transcom Fleet Leasing Scott Monty truck driver Facebook NS 3PLTL driver pay US Auto Sales freight bid USA Truck Entrepreneur CITA Shipper Pulse Survey trucking company acquisitions Business skills computer protection Regina Schneider Logistics economy Omni Channel driver shortages Search engine optimization Failure Anti-Vax Transport Capital Partners (TCP) Dedicated Trucking freight transportation New York Times Reshoring home delibery cars computer security Career Advice financial management Sales US Election Derek Singleton FMS robotics Adrian Gonzalez coaching transportation audit Transportation service CRM FMCSA Social Media in Transportation Montreal Canadiens Emergent Strategy Comey IANA NAFTA professional drivers Global Transportation Hub Freight Management Ferromex freight audit Justice 2013 Economic Forecast dimensional pricing Training New Hires Donald Trump broker security tanker cars Social Media Business Development digital freight matching Rail

Blog Archives

March
February
December
October
September
August
June
May
April
March
January