Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in LTL Freight
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 4609
  • Print

The “Fun” is Back in the LTL Freight Industry

As I look at the LTL freight transportation today, it is hard to believe that just a few years ago, this was one of the most battered sectors of the freight industry. The LTL freight industry took a tremendous pounding during the Great Recession as business volumes contracted by about twenty-five percent. As operating margins shrunk, LTL carriers closed or consolidated terminals and cut staff in an effort to right size ether businesses. Shippers took advantage of the situation by conducting multiple freight bids to leverage their volumes to extract rate concessions.

Seven years later, the industry has changed dramatically and the pendulum has swung back in the carriers’ favour. As volumes return to pre-recession levels, LTL carriers are finding their networks full of freight. As the North American economy improves, manufacturing is on the rise. The near shoring movement is also bringing some manufacturing jobs back to America. In addition, the driver shortage is making it difficult to find drivers, particularly for long haul truckload routes. A clogged intermodal system is limiting the opportunities to divert over the road truckload freight to the rail system. The net result is that some of this freight is being diverted to large LTL shipments so it can move with an LTL carrier. In other words, this is creating traffic for an already full LTL system.

Unlike the truckload sector where even the largest players control only a small (single digit) percent of the total truckload sector, the LTL industry is highly concentrated among a core group of companies. The top 9 LTL carriers in the United States (e.g. FedEx Freight, Con-way, YRC, UPS Freight, Old Dominion, Estes, USF Holland, Reddaway and New Penn, ABF, R & L Carriers and Saia) control almost seventy percent of the LTL market. In Canada, the major players, TransForce (e.g. TST Overland, Canadian Freightways, Kingsway, QuikX, Quiktrax, Clarke Transport and Vitran), the Day and Ross Group and Manitoulin would also control a major share of the LTL market. With limited capacity and pricing discipline, this gives this group of companies considerable pricing power. With high quality costing models, these companies can now seek meaningful rate increases or de-market poor paying accounts. In other words, the “fun” is back in this business.

To further improve yields, FedEx Freight and UPS Freight are introducing density based or dimensional or cube-based pricing. I wrote about the potential of this trend years ago( and it is finally starting to take hold. Just as airlines charge for “bums in seats” and adjust their plane sizes to each route and the potential passenger traffic, LTL freight carriers are going to become much more diligent about charging shippers for the cubic space occupied on their trailers. Shippers with poor packaging, who don’t nest their products effectively or don’t design their products well or load them smartly, will face a nasty surprise. With so much industry consolidation, it won’t take long before dimensional pricing becomes more standard across the industry.

Another reason why LTL carriers are having more “fun” is in their attitudes toward logistics service providers. A few years ago, 3PLs were viewed as the enemy. They were seen as trying to poach LTL customers and replace their carriers by taking control of the direct customer interface. Times have changed. LTL carriers are increasingly viewing 3PLs as business partners. They are forming alliances with companies that have common objectives and customer profiles so they can collectively bring value to the customer. The large LTL carriers are going a step further by creating their own internal logistics or at least freight brokerage arms.

The terminal networks of the large and even medium-sized LTL carriers serve as barriers to entry. As a result, it is not easy to establish an LTL freight business as it is a truckload business. This is producing some new models of LTL carriers. In addition to marketing alliances between regional LTL carriers (to expand market coverage) such as the Reliance Network, we are also seeing the creation of asset lite or even non-asset based (technology driven) LTL players. Roadrunner Transportation Systems and FreightQuote are just two of the companies now targeting this sector using these new models.

The thrill was gone in 2007 and 2008 but the fun is back in 2014.


To stay up to date on the latest trends in freight transportation, click here to obtain a free subscription to Dan’s Transportation Newspaper ( and join the Freight Management Best Practices group ( on LinkedIn. Follow us on Twitter @DanGoodwill.



  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Thursday, 21 September 2017

Most Recent Posts


Tag Cloud

Microsoft Muhammad Ali e-commerce business start-up Training Donald Trump Regina Transloading Education NAFTA rail safety Inbound Transportation Freight Matching Politics Life Lessons University of Tennessee LTL Wal-Mart Transplace US Housing Market 3PL online shopping 2014 freight volumes Global Transportation Hub CSA scores buying trucking companies FMS NMFC risk management driver CN Rail Rotman School of Business Leadership employee termination Retail Crude Oil by Rail Accessorial Charges Success failure entrepreneur Keystone Pipeline US Election Freight Shuttle System US Manufacturing freight RFP BlueGrace Logistics $75000 bond Truckload freight costs Freight Rates CITA Shipper Pulse Survey Doug Davis driver shortages LCV's Canada U.S. trade freight forwarders Canadian truckers freight transportation Canadian freight market capacity shortage US Auto Sales freight transportation in 2011 NCC Map-21 transportation newspaper Social Media in Transportation Spanx routing guide pipelines Warehousing Canada's global strategy Business Transformation Strategy UP Fire Phone selling trucking companies Deferred Packaging Sales Training MPG Training New Hires dynamic pricing freight cost savings shipping FMCSA Amazon Omni Channel economy Freight Rail 2015 Economic Forecast Right Shoring small business economic forecasts for 2012 dimensional pricing Business Strategy Facebook CRM Climate Change RFP drones EBOR mentoring future of freight industry tanker cars bulk shipping transportation audit Freight Capacity Blogging shipper-carrier contracts 2014 economic forecast Consulting Canadian Transportation & Logistics Career Advice Hudsons Bay Company energy efficiency Sales Infrastructure Retail transportation Yield Improvement home delibery freight bid Load Boards automation Canadian economy Software Advice Finance and Transportation Dan Goodwill Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC KCS TMS consumer centric customer engagement Grocery Tracy Matura Trump Surety bond Sales Management Adrian Gonzalez freight agreements Shipper NS fuel surcharge Bobby Harris Social Media Transportation Ferromex cheap oil freight transportation conference freight broker shipping wine Freight Carriers Association of Canada coaching David Tuttle Twitter APL freight audit TMP Worldwide Transportation service freight payment freight audit last mile delivery freight rate increases peak season shipper-carrier collaboration Loblaw capacity shortages intermodal Whole Foods Doug Nix Railway Association of Canada broker bonds Colilers International Business skills 360ideaspace FCA US Economy TransForce Freight Management Driver Shortage 2014 freight forecast Search engine optimization Success robotics derailments Derek Singleton Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration USA Truck Dedicated Trucking Freight contracts Canada truck drivers Masters in Logistics Job satisfaction trucking company acquisitions network optimization Emergent Strategy CSA solutions provider financial management CSX marketing Crisis management Distribution Cleveland Cavaliers freight payment Load broker supply chain management Packaging shipper-carrier roundtable ProMiles Stephen Harper Trade Vision Driving for Profit LinkedIn Werner trade professional drivers BNSF Toronto Dedicated Contract Carriage 3PLTL President Obama transportation news Swift hiring process JB Hunt 2013 Economic Forecast CP Rail MBA Otto New York Times Entrepreneur Rate per Mile Freight Recession Transportation Buying Trends Survey Associates Carriers autonomous vehicles Trucking Outsourcing Sales Transcom Fleet Leasing Global experience Transport Capital Partners (TCP) Schneider Logistics Comey carrier conference natural disasters driverless Failure Management Celadon CN Broker broker security truck driver IANA ShipMax Conway FuelQuest Reshoring Scott Monty FCPC home delivery 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad Harper Davos speech the future of transportation

Blog Archives