Follow us on Twitter!
Blog Header Logo
DG&A's Transportation Consulting Blog
Posted by on in Best Practices in Freight Management
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 2726
  • 0 Comments
  • Print

Freight Management is a Team Sport

b2ap3_thumbnail_dreamstime_l_49902348.jpg

Freight costs represent between two and five percent of revenue in many manufacturers and distributors. They are typically the single largest supply chain expense. When transportation costs begin to escalate, the Transportation department and the Transportation leader can become the “whipping boys” for senior management.

Over the years, we have observed that the companies that are most successful in managing freight costs tend to have a collaborative work environment. They understand that successful freight cost management is most effective in companies where all of the key operating departments - - - Sales, Purchasing, Production, Warehouse and Inventory Management, Customer Service, Transportation and the Customer work together. In other words, freight management is a team sport.

When we visit a new shipper client, there are four things that we typically look for at the outset. They are a:

• 12 month Freight Budget

• 12 month, granular Shipment Activity Report

• 12 month Freight Spend by Carrier Report and

• Routing Guide

A 12 month freight budget, displays the projected and actual freight expenditures by mode by geographic area. We also ask to see a copy of a monthly actual expenditure tracking report by mode by geographic area. This displays how the business is trending and highlights any off-plan or “maverick” spend. It also tells us if they are managing their freight budget.

The 12 month granular shipment activity report displays all shipments in an origin/destination spreadsheet format. This report displays shipment type (i.e. parcel, LTL, truckload), mode (i.e. over the road, intermodal, ocean, air), carrier, shipment actual weight, shipment billed weight, freight (linehaul) rate, fuel surcharge, and accessorial charges (i.e. mall delivery, waiting time etc.) for each shipment. This report will often reveal poor shipping practices (i.e. sending individual rather than consolidated LTL shipments to the same customer on the same day).

The 12 month freight spend activity report by carrier captures information on the money paid to each carrier, for each mode of transport, by geographic area. This tells us how many carriers are being used in each region and the proportion of the business they each have.

The Routing Guide displays the carriers selected as primary and backup for each mode in each region. Once we review and contrast the data in these four reports, they tell us a great deal, not just about the company’s Freight Transportation operation but also much about the other areas of the business. Here are some examples.

Sales Issues

Companies that have a higher than budgeted amount of LTL or expedited freight, may have sales people making commitments to customers on service that fall outside of company norms.

Production Issues

Similarly, companies that experience higher than budgeted LTL or expedited costs may be a result of a variety of production problems. The freight may be coming off the production line so late it is not able to hit daily pick-up schedules or use budgeted or preferred modes.

Warehouse/Inventory Issues

The warehouse footprint in some companies does not allow for an adequate buildup of inventory or necessitate shipping optimized order sizes. It may also reflect inadequate collaboration between central and remote warehouses.

Customer Issues

Customers may not always advise shippers of special promotions or they may make last minute changes to order sizes. In other cases, pallet configurations may result in a poor use of cubic space on a trailer or container.

Transportation Issues

In many cases, we observe a lack of compliance to the published routing guide across multiple company divisions. This can result in the use of carriers that are well down or not even in the routing guide.

Cost overruns are the net result of all of these issues. While much of the responsibility may fall on Transportation, effective freight cost management demands quality data, close collaboration and good communication between multiple departments. The analysis we perform will reveal if the company has the technology (i.e. TMS system) to manage freight. It will highlight “invisible walls” and/or a lack of team work. It may demonstrate a lack of management oversight and discipline. The solutions vary from company to company. They can include any combination of the following: 

Communication with customers on timing of orders, pallet configurations and other items 

Preparation of a quality freight budget and monthly tracking reports 

Acquisition of a TMS system 

Creation of a Transportation Management Council, composed of representatives many most of the key operating departments, that meets on a scheduled basis to address inefficiencies and cost overruns

Stronger management and closer supervision.

One should never forget that freight costs are variable expenses that can be effectively managed and controlled. Companies with superior supply chains can use them as a competitive weapon.

 

To stay up to date on Best Practices in Freight Management, follow me on Twitter @DanGoodwill, join the Freight Management Best Practices group on LinkedIn and subscribe to Dan’s Transportation Newspaper (http://paper.li/DanGoodwill/1342211466).

0

Comments

  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Thursday, 28 March 2024

Most Recent Posts

Search


Tag Cloud

Load broker Blogging Leafs Map-21 Load Boards Sales Strategy buying trucking companies Anti-Vax driver pay Truckload David Tuttle Distribution customer engagement NS Canadian freight market Justice CITA Shipper Pulse Survey trucking company acquisitions Habs NCC bulk shipping shipper-carrier roundtable cars Success failure entrepreneur Transportation Buying Trends Survey truck drivers Warehousing Loblaw Driving for Profit Dedicated Trucking Freight Rates 2012 Transportation Business Strategies. Jugaad routing guide Business Transformation Strategy CSA EBOR Surety bond Microsoft Harper Davos speech MPG Accessorial Charges LTL Cleveland Cavaliers home delibery computer natural disasters Dan Goodwill Right Shoring Shipper Freight Carriers Association of Canada freight payment freight audit automation e-commerce autos last mile delivery Failure solutions provider YRCW LCV's Omni Channel Canadian Transportation & Logistics freight costs Blockchain Celadon Spanx drones online shopping Crisis management recession dimensional pricing Canada-U.S. trade agreement YRC Emergent Strategy Packaging Sales transportation news small business Colilers International Business skills professional drivers the future of transportation Tariffs Wal-Mart computer protection Freight Capacity Adrian Gonzalez economic forecasts for 2012 freight payment home delivery energy efficiency freight marketplace tanker cars Rotman School of Business Government US Auto Sales Entrepreneur FMCSA FCPC freight cost savings marketing Management University of Tennessee freight bid Canadian truckers Canada's global strategy Conway Transportation service coaching Swift robotics Associates selling trucking companies truck driver economic outlook FuelQuest Climate Change IANA consumer centric Rail Crude Oil by Rail CN 360ideaspace Carriers MBA 3PLTL business security Transloading shipping cyber security laptop Outsourcing Sales economy Retail transportation employee termination Twitter Railway Association of Canada rail safety Transcom Fleet Leasing ShipMax peak season future of freight industry freight broker truck capacity 2014 economic forecast 2013 Economic Forecast Success BNSF Montreal Canadiens US Economy Job satisfaction Search engine optimization Deferred Packaging LinkedIn Sales Training shipper-carrier contracts technology ProMiles FMS Global experience KCS $75000 bond Freight Matching Rate per Mile TransForce Online grocery shopping Life Lessons Masters in Logistics FCA Facebook Business Development ELD Consulting Covid-19 RFP Scott Monty Canada New York Times freight transportation conference freight forwarders Trump JB Hunt carrier conference Uber Freight Driver Shortage asset management broker security Reshoring Geopolitics CRM Freight contracts business start-up dark stores Keystone Pipeline Comey Doug Davis 2014 freight volumes Whole Foods Freight Recession Canadian economy Broker Doug Nix shipping wine Trucking Horizontal Supply Chain Collaboration driver shortages driverless Business Strategy freight audit UP Impeachment US Housing Market Politics Donald Trump Sales Management Hockey Toronto Maple Leafs Regina Freight hiring process pipelines trade network optimization China freight transportation APL Stephen Harper Trade Vision Leadership Canada U.S. trade Bobby Harris TMS transportation newspaper computer security NMFC Global Transportation Hub Derek Singleton freight agreements Toronto Infrastructure driver intermodal small parcel dynamic pricing Inbound Transportation Electric Vehicles shipper-carrier collaboration Otto USMCA Hudsons Bay Company freight rate increases Digital Freight Networks freight RFP BlueGrace Logistics US Election 2015 Economic Forecast 3PL transportation audit Finance and Transportation Transplace Freight Management Social Media Grocery NAFTA US Manufacturing financial management 2014 freight forecast capacity shortages broker bonds Social Media in Transportation Canadian Protests Software Advice supply chain management Ferromex CN Rail Transportation mentoring Tracy Matura derailments General Motors Trucker Protest Transport Capital Partners (TCP) USA Truck Fire Phone cheap oil TMP Worldwide digital freight matching Muhammad Ali Amazon Freight Shuttle System Career Advice Value Proposition CP Rail fuel surcharge CSX autonomous vehicles Retail Schneider Logistics Coronavirus Digitization risk management Training President Obama CSA scores freight transportation in 2011 Training New Hires Dedicated Contract Carriage Education Yield Improvement Werner capacity shortage

Blog Archives

March
February
December
October
September
August
June
May
April
March
January